Accident Forgiveness

Accident forgiveness is a rate-protection feature: it stops your insurer from applying the standard at-fault accident surcharge after your first at-fault accident. It does not forgive the deductible, does not pay the other party, and does not remove the accident from your motor-vehicle record or CLUE loss history. It is a premium benefit, not a claims benefit.

This page explains what the feature is, how carriers run it, and when buying or earning it pays off. For a ranked carrier shortlist with direct quote paths, see best car insurance with accident forgiveness.

How to know if you have accident forgiveness

Three places to check, in order of reliability:

1. Your declarations page. This is the single-page policy summary your insurer sends at each renewal. Named endorsements (including accident forgiveness) appear in the coverage summary or the endorsements list. The policy form number for the endorsement, if applicable, is printed next to the coverage line.
2. Your policy's endorsements list. The full policy document includes a list of all endorsements attached. On Progressive, look for "Small Accident Forgiveness" and/or "Large Accident Forgiveness." On Allstate, "Accident Forgiveness" appears as part of the Platinum package. On Nationwide and Liberty Mutual, the endorsement name is "Accident Forgiveness."
3. Online account or carrier app. Most carriers list active discounts and endorsements under the policy details screen. If the carrier shows a "potential" or "eligible" status, you have not yet earned it; you have the earning path open to you (typically 5 claim-free years at that carrier).

If none of the three show accident forgiveness, you do not have it. Call the carrier to add it as a paid endorsement where available. On a State Farm policy, there is no named accident forgiveness product to find; State Farm uses a tenure-based rate stability approach instead.

What accident forgiveness actually does

• Prevents the first at-fault surcharge. After a covered at-fault accident, your renewal premium does not jump from the surcharge the carrier would otherwise apply (typically 30 to 50 percent).
• Scope: typically one accident per policy per lifetime of the feature. The second at-fault accident surcharges normally.
• Scope: typically policyholder-only. If a listed driver other than the named insured is at fault, forgiveness often does not apply.
• Scope: at-fault only. Not-at-fault accidents don't need forgiveness; they typically don't surcharge in the first place.

YesWeSure may receive compensation when readers use quote-comparison links. See our advertiser disclosure and editorial standards.

What accident forgiveness does NOT do

• Doesn't forgive the deductible. You still pay collision or comprehensive deductible as normal.
• Doesn't pay the other party differently. Your liability coverage pays the other driver's damages exactly as it would without forgiveness.
• Doesn't erase the accident. It stays on your motor-vehicle record and your CLUE loss history for the normal 3 to 5 year lookback. If you switch carriers, the new carrier can and usually will surcharge for it.
• Doesn't cover criminal or egregious conduct. DUI, reckless driving, hit-and-run, and criminal convictions typically void forgiveness.

Carriers and how their programs work

• Allstate

  Paid add-on, part of the Platinum package. Available immediately on sign-up with no earn-in period. See the Allstate review.

• Progressive

  Small Accident Forgiveness is automatic for new customers in most states and keeps rates flat for a first claim at or below $500. Large Accident Forgiveness requires 5+ years with Progressive and up to 5 consecutive accident- and violation-free years, then forgives one accident of any size.

• Liberty Mutual

  Earned after 5 years accident-free as a Liberty Mutual customer. Also available as a paid upgrade. See the Liberty Mutual review.

• Nationwide

  Paid add-on, available at bind. See the Nationwide review.

• Travelers

  Premier Responsible Driver Plan bundles accident forgiveness with other long-tenure benefits for safe-driver policyholders. See the Travelers review.

State Farm does not file a named accident forgiveness product; it uses a tenure-based rate stability approach instead. See the State Farm review.

When it is worth buying

• You have multiple drivers in the household (teen or young adult drivers).
• Your 10-year driving history has at least one at-fault event (base rate for the surcharge risk).
• The paid add-on costs less than the expected-value of a single surcharge over the next 3 to 5 years. The math is favorable at most carriers for high-risk households and unfavorable for clean-record single-driver policies.

Already had a minor incident and wondering whether to file it? Our should I file a claim tool weighs the deductible, likely surcharge, and your accident forgiveness status before you call the carrier.